Should juries get eviction cases? Nebraska Supreme Court to hear lawsuit

OMAHA, Neb. (WOWT) – Eviction hearings may be over within the blink of a watch.

Authorized help lawyer Caitlin Cedfeldt calls a day like Wednesday a rocket docket. Practically 90 eviction hearings in two hours. That averages out to lower than 90 seconds per listening to. Every case is determined by one man: the choose.

In accordance with a Nebraska legislation, it’s as much as a choose to find out if you need to be faraway from your house. Authorized Assist of Nebraska argues that goes in opposition to the constitutional proper to a jury trial.

They’re taking the difficulty all the way in which to the Nebraska Supreme Courtroom.

“The idea of the attraction is the best to a jury trial. So we’re saying that even landlord-tenant eviction instances have a proper to a jury trial,” stated Caitlin Cedfeldt.

Cedfeldt represents Teresa Holcomb within the appellate case. She was evicted for allegedly threatening different neighbors. Her eviction was upheld by two judges.

“I believe {that a} jury of friends could be higher geared up to guage the information than only a choose on the bench who perhaps sees all these instances on a regular basis,” stated Cedfeldt.

One argument in opposition to jury trials in eviction proceedings is that it may extend the method and demand extra assets. However the director of Authorized Assist of Nebraska says it’s price it if it provides folks a good shake.

“The counterargument of taking assets, taking time, completely. However we’ve got a justice system that’s arrange to make sure that rights are enforced and to make sure equity. Generally that takes time,” stated Laurie Heer Dale, govt director of Authorized Assist of Nebraska.

Cedfedlt doesn’t assume that jury trials in eviction proceedings would plague the justice system.

“If we win, is there going to be a jury trial on each single case? I don’t assume so. The rationale I might say that’s as a result of not each single case that now that is eligible for a jury trial will get one.”

Oral arguments have been alleged to be heard Thursday, however the court docket requested for the Nebraska lawyer basic to weigh in on this constitutional query. Now they’ll be heard within the first week of December. An opinion would come within the following months.

The ACLU of Nebraska wrote a “good friend of court docket” transient in favor of jury trials in eviction proceedings. They declare it’s a matter of particular significance for girls, kids, and other people with disabilities.

Two years in the past, an try like this by the ACLU of Idaho was profitable.

Copyright 2022 WOWT. All rights reserved.