Opinion: Don’t politicize prosecutions in Iowa

Throughout her speech, Gov. Kim Reynolds embraces candidate for Iowa Legal professional Basic Brenna Fowl throughout a women-led Republican rally at World Class Industries in Cedar Rapids, Iowa on Tuesday, October 25, 2022. Fowl is working in opposition to present Legal professional Basic Tom Miller. (Savannah Blake/The Gazette)

Adjustments proposed for the Iowa Legal professional Basic’s Workplace as a part of a large authorities reorganization invoice could be unhealthy information for the precept of native management and for shoppers affected by Iowa Utilities Board selections. The measures mustn’t turn into regulation.

One provision of the invoice states, “The legal professional basic could prosecute a felony continuing on behalf of the state even when a county legal professional doesn’t request the legal professional basic to behave as a county legal professional.”

The Legal professional Basic’s Workplace insists state regulation already permits the legal professional basic to deal with native circumstances with out the county legal professional’s request and calls this clarifying language. However it’s unclear why lawmakers felt the necessity to emphasize this level within the reorganization invoice. It appears apparent that legislators imagine new Republican Legal professional Basic Brenna Fowl ought to take a extra lively position in native prosecutions.

That’s a troubling break with the lengthy custom instituted by former Legal professional Basic Tom Miller, who stepped into native circumstances solely when requested. We perceive Fowl’s election brings adjustments, however deferring to domestically elected prosecutors was a prudent course we expect Fowl ought to observe.

In any other case, we may even see our system of justice devolve right into a politicized battle between Fowl and native county attorneys, seemingly in majority Democratic counties. The place as soon as existed a useful partnership, the state may turn into a bully wielding energy in opposition to native county attorneys.

The precept of native management, as soon as lauded by Republicans, has been shredded throughout their years of Statehouse management. This could be yet one more tear within the rights of native voters who elect officers to make native selections.

The reorganization invoice additionally offers the legal professional basic “unique jurisdiction” over all election-related crimes. We’re puzzled as to why the legal professional basic would need jurisdiction over election regulation violations which are usually minor offenses. Once more, we see the distinct chance of those circumstances being politicized by a Republican legal professional basic searching for to supply justification for voting restrictions.

Additionally underneath the reorganization invoice, the as soon as impartial Workplace of Client Advocate could be positioned underneath direct management of the legal professional basic. The patron advocate represents shoppers in circumstances the come earlier than the Iowa Utilities Board, together with permitting carbon seize pipelines to grab land via eminent area for his or her tasks.

Underneath present regulation, the advocate serves a hard and fast time period shielded from political affect. Underneath the invoice, the advocate would serve “on the pleasure of the legal professional basic.” The advocate would not be required to be a “competent legal professional,” blunting the advocate’s skill to symbolize shoppers in court docket. Attorneys and help workers on the OCA could be picked by the legal professional basic.”

These clarifications and adjustments add as much as an pointless energy seize that might hurt Iowans. Reorganization ought to enhance authorities, not make it much less accountable and accessible.

(319) 398-8262; editorial@thegazette.com

Opinion content material represents the point of view of the creator or The Gazette editorial board. You’ll be able to be part of the dialog by submitting a letter to the editor or visitor column or by suggesting a subject for an editorial to editorial@thegazette.com