Inside Edition host Eva Pilgrim discusses strategies for securing Valentine’s Day reservations and Nancy Guthrie kidnapping

INDIANAPOLIS (WISH) — Inside Edition host Eva Pilgrim shared strategies for securing last-minute Valentine’s Day reservations and provided updates on the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation in Tucson during an appearance on WISH-TV.

Pilgrim encouraged diners to call restaurants directly rather than relying solely on reservation apps, saying personal communication and flexibility can improve the chances of booking a table during the busy holiday weekend. She also suggested considering larger party sizes, lunch reservations or celebrating on an alternate date to increase availability.

For those unable to secure reservations, Pilgrim noted that many couples are opting to celebrate at home by cooking meals themselves or ordering takeout, emphasizing that the holiday is centered more on spending time together than on a specific setting.

Pilgrim also discussed the kidnapping investigation involving Nancy Guthrie in Tucson. Correspondent Jim Murray is reporting from the scene as authorities continue to release new details in the rapidly developing case.

She said the investigation has drawn widespread national attention as the public awaits further information from law enforcement. Pilgrim also addressed the role of social media in modern news stories, noting that online speculation often spreads quickly and requires careful verification by journalists.

Pilgrim described the case as especially personal within the media community because of the victim’s connection to Savannah Guthrie, adding that journalists aim to balance public interest with sensitivity toward the families involved.

“Inside Edition” airs weekdays at 7 p.m. on WISH-TV. Authorities in Tucson are expected to provide additional updates as the investigation continues.