US Marshals arrest 2 men accused of killing Maple Heights man in robbery outside Angie’s Soul Café

CLEVELAND, Ohio (WOIO) – The U.S. Marshals confirmed the two suspects wanted by the Cleveland Division of Police for the murder of a Maple Heights man robbed outside Angie’s Soul Café in June have been arrested.

Members of the U.S. Marshals’ Northern Ohio Violent Fugitive Task Force arrested 20-year-old Dominick Newby and 19-year-old Jayshawn Collins early Wednesday morning without incident, USMS stated.

They were found in the 1100 block of East 58th Street in Cleveland, USMS said.

Cleveland police said officers rushed to the 700 block of Carnegie Avenue at 2:30 p.m. on June 17 for a reported robbery outside Angie’s Soul Café.

Officers then learned the victim was shot in the parking lot during a robbery, according to police.

He was taken to University Hospitals where he died.

The Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner identified him as 34-year-old Patrick Carner of Maple Heights.

Restaurant staff told 19 News the victim was a customer who had come to purchase food and was shot while getting in a car.

A representative from the restaurant released the below statement on June 17:

19 News confirmed through officials that Carner was the man sentenced in connection to the death of his pregnant ex-girlfriend.

Vonnashia Akins died after falling out of a moving car on I-90 in downtown Cleveland during rush hour back in October 2019.

Carner was behind the wheel, and police said he left the scene.

He was sentenced to a total of four years for obstruction of official business and tampering with evidence.

Newby and Collins were identified as suspects in this murder late this summer, USMS said, and the NOVFTF recently started searching for both of them.

“This shooting left one person dead and could have been significantly worse as the shooting took place outside of a busy restaurant in the middle of the day,” U.S. Marshal Pete Elliott stated. “The community is a safer place with these two violent individuals off the streets and behind bars.”

Anyone with information on a wanted fugitive can call the Northern Ohio Violent Fugitive Task Force at 1-866-4WANTED (1-866-492-6833), or you send a tip online.

Reward money is available for tips leading to the arrest and conviction of a wanted fugitive, and tipsters can stay anonymous.

This is a developing story. Return to 19 News for updates.

Copyright 2025 WOIO. All rights reserved.