Donald Trump invokes 5th Amendment rights, declines to answer NY attorney general questions

WASHINGTON — Former President Donald Trump invoked his Fifth Modification rights and declined to reply questions from the New York legal professional normal at a scheduled deposition Wednesday.

“Underneath the recommendation of my counsel and for the entire above causes, I declined to reply the questions beneath the rights and privileges afforded to each citizen beneath america Structure,” Trump mentioned in a press release.

Trump was to be deposed by legal professionals from New York Lawyer Normal Letitia James’ workplace as a part of a greater than three-year civil investigation into whether or not the Trump Group misled lenders, insurers and tax authorities by offering them deceptive monetary statements.

Trump mentioned in a publish on Reality Social earlier Wednesday morning that he can be “seeing” James “for a continuation of the best Witch Hunt in U.S. historical past! My nice firm, and myself, are being attacked from all sides. Banana Republic!”

Trump was seen leaving Trump Tower in New York Metropolis on Wednesday morning, and his motorcade arrived on the New York legal professional normal’s workplace shortly after.

The scheduled deposition comes throughout a unprecedented authorized week for the previous President. On Monday, the FBI executed a search warrant at Mar-a-Lago, his major residence in Florida, in reference to an investigation into the dealing with of categorized paperwork. On Tuesday, a federal appeals court docket denied his long-running effort to dam a Home committee from acquiring his tax returns.

Some Trump advisers had advocated that the previous President reply questions since he beforehand testified about his monetary statements beneath oath, whereas others warned him in opposition to offering any solutions due to the potential authorized jeopardy he could face, individuals aware of the matter inform CNN. The Manhattan district legal professional has a separate ongoing legal investigation into the Trump Group.

One other consideration that had been mentioned, the individuals acquainted say, is the political implications of not answering questions as Trump is extensively anticipated to announce that he’ll run for president in 2024. Whereas campaigning in 2016, Trump urged not answering questions was an indication of guilt. At a marketing campaign cease in Iowa in 2016, Trump mentioned, “Should you’re harmless, why are you taking the Fifth Modification?”

In his assertion Wednesday, Trump mentioned, “Now I do know the reply to that query” and decried James’ investigation. The previous President and the Trump Group have beforehand denied any wrongdoing.

“When your loved ones, your organization, and all of the individuals in your orbit have grow to be the targets of an unfounded, politically motivated Witch Hunt supported by legal professionals, prosecutors, and the Pretend Information Media, you haven’t any selection,” the previous President said.

In January, James’ workplace mentioned it discovered “important” proof indicating the Trump Group used false or deceptive asset valuations in its monetary statements to acquire loans, insurance coverage and tax advantages. The legal professional normal’s civil investigation is nearing the top and a choice over an enforcement motion could come quickly.

The showdown follows Trump’s failed try to dam subpoenas for depositions from him and his kids, Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka Trump.

Ivanka Trump’s deposition came about final week and Trump Jr. had his deposition in late July, individuals aware of the matter mentioned.

Trump Jr., who runs the Trump Group along with his brother Eric Trump, and Ivanka Trump didn’t assert their Fifth Modification rights and answered the state’s questions, the individuals mentioned. It isn’t clear what they have been particularly requested or what they mentioned. Their choice breaks with Eric Trump and former Trump Group Chief Monetary Officer Allen Weisselberg, who each asserted their Fifth Modification rights greater than 500 instances when deposed in 2020.

Trump has testified beneath oath in civil lawsuits over the previous a long time and since leaving workplace he has additionally been deposed. Final yr he supplied videotaped testimony for a lawsuit involving an assault exterior of Trump Tower. The case is about to go to trial within the fall. Trump has denied any wrongdoing.

Questions on Trump’s web value

Trump has been questioned concerning the accuracy of his web value and monetary statements in earlier lawsuits, one thing some advisers say is one cause why he ought to reply questions within the present investigation.

In a 2007 deposition in a defamation lawsuit, Trump as soon as mentioned he calculated his web value, to a level, on his “emotions,” and that he put the “finest spin” on among the property. “I feel everyone” exaggerates concerning the worth of their properties, he testified, including: “Who would not?”

Did he inflate values? “Not past cause,” Trump mentioned.

Prior to now Trump has tried to push accountability for his valuation selections onto Weisselberg, whereas on the identical time, paperwork and depositions seem to point out that, whilst Trump claimed that he left these valuation selections to others, he was additionally deeply concerned in working his enterprise.

Trump mentioned within the 2007 deposition that the one particular person he handled in making ready the statements of monetary situation was Weisselberg.

“I might give my opinion,” Trump mentioned within the deposition. “We’ll discuss it,” he mentioned, including that “finally” and “predominately” it was Weisselberg who got here up with the ultimate values, which Trump mentioned he seen as “conservative.”

When questioned particularly about swings in values from one yr to the following Trump had prepared explanations.

Throughout the deposition, Trump was questioned over the household compound in Westchester County, New York, known as Seven Springs the place its worth almost doubled in a single yr from $80 million in 2005 to $150 million in 2006.

“The property was valued very low, for my part, then and it turned very — it simply has gone up,” Trump mentioned.

He was requested if he had any foundation for that view, apart from his personal opinion.

“I do not consider so, no,” he mentioned.

Along with Weisselberg, two others concerned within the preparation of the monetary statements, Jeff McConney, the Trump Group’s controller, and Donald Bender, the actual property agency’s exterior accountant, have each been interviewed by the legal professional normal’s workplace and Manhattan district legal professional.

Trump’s legal professionals are more likely to argue that the monetary statements weren’t audited so anybody counting on them can be on discover. The monetary statements reviewed by CNN present they’ve quite a few disclosures indicating that they didn’t conform with usually accepted accounting rules. As well as, not one of the lenders misplaced cash on the transactions, which may make it tougher to allege that they have been defrauded or misled.

The value determinations underlying the property values have been in lots of circumstances supplied by Trump’s longtime appraiser Cushman & Wakefield, which can be beneath investigation. Cushman, which broke ties with Trump after the Capitol riot on January 6, 2021, has denied any wrongdoing and stands by its work.

Authorized dangers to Trump

The depositions pose important authorized dangers to the Trumps.

If Trump is sued by James and the case goes to trial, the jury can draw an “hostile inference” in opposition to him for not answering questions, which may end in a better judgment in opposition to him if he is discovered liable. If he solutions questions, it may open the door to potential civil and legal legal responsibility.

The legal investigation, led by Manhattan District Lawyer Alvin Bragg, has slowed however not stopped. Earlier this yr, Bragg wouldn’t authorize prosecutors to current proof earlier than a state grand jury after elevating issues concerning the energy of the case, CNN has reported. A particular grand jury listening to proof within the case expired in April, however a brand new one could possibly be seated sooner or later.

Bragg instructed CNN in an interview in April: “Anytime you could have a parallel civil, legal investigation, if there’s testimony in that continuing, clearly we are going to take a look at it.”

The-CNN-Wire & 2022 Cable Information Community, Inc., a WarnerMedia Firm. All rights reserved.