Ticketmaster gets a bipartisan grilling on Capitol Hill

It was solely a matter of time earlier than a politician awkwardly quoted Taylor Swift at Tuesday morning’s Senate Judiciary Committee listening to on Ticketmaster, Reside Nation and the U.S. ticketing market.

“Might I counsel respectfully that Ticketmaster should look within the mirror and say, ‘I’m the issue. It’s me’” Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) instructed Reside Nation Leisure’s President and Chief Monetary Officer Joe Berchtold, referencing the refrain to Swift’s No. 1 music, “Anti-Hero.” “The reason being, fairly merely, that you’re those finally liable for the astronomically rising costs, the exorbitant hidden charges, the sold-out reveals and the bots and scalpers.”

In November, Ticketmaster bungled the on-sale for Swift’s upcoming stadium tour, prompting outcry from demoralized followers who have been left ticket-less and, quickly thereafter, criticism from a spread of politicians and a class-action lawsuit from disgruntled Swifties. Tuesday’s listening to, led by Senators Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) and Mike Lee (R-Utah), confirmed bipartisan skepticism in direction of the Reside Nation/Ticketmaster conglomerate, which dominates the reside music market.

Critics contend that Reside Nation, which merged with Ticketmaster in 2010, exerts undue energy over the live performance trade. Reside Nation is the nation’s largest live performance promoter, whereas Ticketmaster controls an estimated 80% of the ticketing market. The businesses have been allowed to merge underneath a Division of Justice consent decree that pressured Ticketmaster to license its software program and prohibited retaliatory conduct towards rivals.

Tuesday’s listening to, which featured testimony from ticketing executives, impartial promoters, antitrust specialists and artists, scrutinized the corporate’s alleged anticompetitive practices, excessive service charges and incapability to weed out automated scalpers from the ticket-buying course of. The aggressive line of questioning from each Democratic and Republican senators made clear that there’s a actual regulatory and legislative menace to Reside Nation and Ticketmaster’s enterprise mannequin — and maybe its future as a single firm.

“Innovation in reside occasion ticketing has been stunted as a result of Reside Nation Leisure Inc. controls the most well-liked entertainers on the earth, the ticketing techniques, and even lots of the venues,” mentioned Jack Groetzinger, co-founder and chief govt officer of SeatGeek, a direct competitor to Ticketmaster. “This energy over the complete reside leisure trade permits Reside Nation to keep up its monopolistic affect over the first ticketing market. So long as Reside Nation stays each the dominant live performance promoter and ticketer of main venues in the US, our trade will proceed to wrestle with the challenges that face it at this time.”

Clyde Lawrence, singer for the New York soul-pop band Lawrence, mentioned that “ever since we began touring, we seen what felt like lopsided deal mechanics in sure elements of the reside music trade.”

Reside Nation’s “horizontal and vertical attain makes it onerous to create competitors,” he continued. “Corporations within the ticketing area would possibly carry main improvements that permit for decrease charges, higher transparency … and developments in dealing with the problematic secondary ticketing market … Nevertheless it doesn’t matter how modern these different ticketing corporations are; if each Reside Nation present must be ticketed completely by means of Ticketmaster, there’s no probability for them to interrupt by means of.”

Kathleen Bradish, of the American Antitrust Institute, went even additional.

“Reside Nation / Ticketmaster is a monopoly,” she mentioned, “and can act as a result of it has an enormous incentive to exclude competitors.”

“Ticketmaster comes underneath a variety of criticism,” Berchtold acknowledged in his opening remarks. “However I can say with nice confidence that technologically Ticketmaster is a significantly better ticketing system at this time than it was in 2010. Its efficiency in massive on-sales is the perfect within the trade, it has the perfect advertising and marketing capabilities of any ticketing system and it’s far and away the chief in stopping fraud and getting tickets into the arms of actual followers.”

Over three hours of testimony and questioning, practically each senator attending had no less than some angle to criticize the agency.

“Again in 2018, 1000’s of individuals in Hawaii tried and didn’t get Bruno Mars tickets,” mentioned Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii)
. “I’ve heard Mr. Berchtold say that after the merger, they spent $1 billion to enhance the Ticketmaster system. So I’m simply questioning what sort of enhancements to the Ticketmaster system are literally being adopted?

“I’m towards dumb, and the best way firm dealt with the on-sale for Ms. Swift was a debacle,” mentioned John Kennedy (R-La.). “Whoever was accountable for that ought to be fired.”

Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) raised considerations that the corporate wasn’t doing sufficient to battle bots or automated scalping. “You’ve got blamed bot assaults on inflicting the the crash throughout the Taylor Swift ticket gross sales. Ticket distributors appear to view bot assaults as regular to their operations,” Blackburn mentioned. “That is an unacceptable scenario.”

Music followers protest towards Ticketmaster outdoors the U.S. Capitol on Tuesday.

(Drew Angerer / Getty Pictures)

Advertisement

A number of audio system introduced up the current changeover at Brooklyn’s Barclays Middle, which reverted again to Ticketmaster after ending a contract with SeatGeek one 12 months right into a seven-year deal. Some on the panel suspected Reside Nation had retaliated to Barclays’ SeatGeek deal by shifting its concert events elsewhere.

“The Barclays Middle noticed a marked lower within the variety of concert events from Reside Nation that have been despatched to that venue versus historic averages,” Groetzinger mentioned. “Administration got here to us and mentioned we wish to have the ability to use Ticketmaster to ticket concert events, and we seemed into it and couldn’t get the economics to work.”

“The DOJ pointed to a pervasive atmosphere of concern of retaliation,” Bradish agreed. “And because of this, it reveals that when an organization has incentives to behave in a specific method, a consent decree isn’t essentially going to cease them from doing that.”

The Division of Justice has an ongoing investigation into Reside Nation’s practices.

“To the people who find themselves fed up, I might say, proceed your criticism in case you’re offended and annoyed,” Blumenthal mentioned. “You bought the facility to demand motion, and we should always act with new laws. If the Division of Justice established a violation of the consent decree, unwinding the merger should be on the desk.

“If the Division of Justice establishes information that contain monopolistic and predatory abuses, there should be structural cures,” he continued. “Reminiscent of breaking apart the corporate.”