Education
How Anne Frank Is Linked to a Sapling on Staten Island
Good morning. It’s Tuesday. We’ll find out how a cutting of a tree that Anne Frank saw while in hiding during World War II ended up on a college campus on Staten Island. We’ll also get details on former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, who was hospitalized with pneumonia in Florida.
From the window in her family’s hiding place in Nazi-occupied Amsterdam, Anne Frank could see a chestnut tree in a courtyard garden nearby. One day, she wrote in her diary that raindrops shone on the branches, “appearing like silver.” On another day, she noted that the tree was “thickly covered with leaves and much more beautiful than last year.”
In 2011, the tree — by then diseased and rotting — was knocked down in a storm. But cuttings have given rise to saplings. One has just been planted at Wagner College on Staten Island.
The view could not be more different. Lori Weintrob, a professor at Wagner, called the college’s 105-acre campus “an idyllic space up on a hill” with a view of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. She said the idea of a bridge was appropriate for the Wagner College Holocaust Center, of which she is the founding director. The center, she said, works to build bridges between the campus and the community and encourages dialogue among Jews, Muslims, Christians and Hindus.
“Staten Island, like New York City, is a melting pot,” Weintrob said, “so this is a great place to create these relationships, to inspire students by showing how you can connect people of different faiths.”
But the campus is also a place to teach Anne’s story — and the story of the people in her life who were “upstanders,” as Weintrob called those who did the right thing under extreme pressure.
Weintrob said the tree “symbolized the freedom she was longing for and that, if she hadn’t been deported to Auschwitz and Bergen-Belsen, that she might have been able to attain.” And she mentioned Miep Gies, the secretary who helped Anne while she was in hiding — and preserved her diary.
“Sometimes Anne Frank’s story is interpreted more as being hopeful, but we have to put it in the context that she doesn’t survive, that there’s the reality of that and that the Jewish community in the Netherlands was obliterated by the Holocaust,” Weintrob said. “So the emphasis is that even though these people who resisted or did extraordinary deeds are the exceptions, they are the role models.”
Weintrob said that Leo Ullman — who, like Anne, spent time in hiding in Amsterdam during World War II — and his wife, Katherine, approached Wagner last year about donating a tree for the campus. “The significance to me is to keep the story of the Holocaust in people’s minds,” he said. “I believe that the tree is relatable.” He also mentioned Weintrob’s work and that of her colleague at the center, Laura Morowitz.
Ullman is a former chairman of the Anne Frank Center USA, which had made plans in the early 2000s to import 10 saplings from the tree in Amsterdam, then more than 150 years old and weakened by a fungal infection. Municipal officials in Amsterdam had decided that it needed to come down; the backlash that followed prompted them to brace the tree with a structural support, but it was no match for the storm in 2011.
The Wagner seedling’s path wound through the Midwest. One of the seedlings from the tree in Amsterdam was bound for the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis. Lauren Bairnsfather, the chief executive of the Anne Frank Center USA, said that seedling was quarantined in a nursery in Indiana, where horticulturists “made grafts from the original tree” that grew into saplings, including the one for Wagner. Two others have been planted in New York City.
Bairnsfather said Wagner was a noteworthy site because the Holocaust center has focused on women’s experiences in the Holocaust, which she said were often neglected in scholarly studies and teaching. But she also said the spot where the tree was planted made a statement.
“They chose that location so when people come to campus, this is what they see,” she said. “We want the tree to become part of the identity.”
Weather
Expect sunny skies and a high in the low 80s. Tonight, there will be increasing clouds with a low around 63.
ALTERNATE-SIDE PARKING
In effect until May 14 (Solemnity of the Ascension).
QUOTE OF THE DAY
“The building is going to be out of service, pending repairs.” — David Simms, an assistant fire chief, after an electrical fire damaged the Eugene O’Neill Theater. As a result, “The Book of Mormon,” which has run there for 15 years, has canceled performances today and tomorrow, and producers did not say when they would resume.
The latest Metro news
Giuliani remains in critical condition
Former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani remained in critical condition yesterday, recovering from pneumonia in a hospital in Florida, his spokesman said.
The spokesman, Ted Goodman, said that Giuliani, 81, had needed a ventilator to breathe after he was hospitalized. But Goodman said yesterday that the former mayor was now breathing on his own. Goodman also said that Giuliani “is the ultimate fighter — as he has demonstrated throughout his life — and he is winning this battle.”
Goodman announced on Sunday that Giuliani was in the hospital but did not say then what his symptoms were. Goodman said yesterday that Giuliani had been diagnosed with restrictive airway disease stemming from his proximity to ground zero in Manhattan after the Sept. 11 attacks in 2001. The condition makes respiratory illnesses more threatening, Goodman said.
My colleague Jonah E. Bromwich writes that it is unclear whether Giuliani has publicly mentioned such a diagnosis before. But the former mayor has noted that he was a frequent presence at the Trade Center site, and in recent years his lawyers have alluded to potential lung disease related to toxicity from the attacks.
Last summer, Giuliani sustained a fractured vertebra when the car he was a passenger in was rear-ended in New Hampshire, where he had become a regular as he seemed to let his attachment to New York wane. He arrived in a wheelchair at the annual ceremony at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum in Lower Manhattan in September. He was photographed that day smiling with a body brace strapped under his suit jacket, over his shirt and tie.
METROPOLITAN diary
Along the park
Dear Diary:
It was April Fools’ Day, and the weather kept changing from sunny to drizzle, as if the gusty wind was moving the sun back and forth behind a cloud.
I put my jacket on and off as I walked along Prospect Park. The trees were still bare, but spring was slowly awakening with yellow forsythias, and every child walking by stared at my new purple hair, hungry for color.
A guy in the bike lane yelled, “Hey!”
I turned to him.
“Sorry,” he said, pointing to someone else. “I’m talking to this guy.”
“But you actually look familiar,” I said.
“So do you,” he said, laughing.
I entered the park to hear pop music near the band shell. Two people with a portable speaker were dancing.
I wanted to join the party, but I realized that I hear the music, so I’m in the party. I danced along from a distance.
From high above, hundreds of blackbirds swooped down like falling peppercorn into the black-and-white woods ahead. As I got closer, I saw specks of tiny green buds emerging on each tree limb.
I left the park, passing three people who had converged because their dogs could not contain their joy. The people laughed like old friends, but within seconds they had walked off separate ways.
As I passed Seeley Street, I overheard a friend through the open window, cheering on a drum student.
I laughed. I should be getting home before the possible rain, I thought, but today, everywhere was home.
— Mare Berger
Illustrated by Agnes Lee. Tell us your New York story here and read more Metropolitan Diary here.
Education
Italian City, Unused to Celebrity Visits, Welcomes Princess of Wales
Italians have little interest in restoring their monarchy, abolished in the 1940s for its support of Mussolini.
But on Wednesday, hundreds of excited residents took to a square in the northern city of Reggio Emilia to loudly cheer the arrival of Catherine, Princess of Wales, on her first official overseas engagement since her battle with cancer was revealed in 2024.
People waved Italian flags and Union Jacks when Catherine arrived in front of City Hall, where she greeted the mayor along with dozens of fidgety preschoolers who were the reason for her trip to this city. For decades, Reggio Emilia has enjoyed international renown for an educational philosophy that focuses on children’s relationships, their enthusiasm and their play.
Catherine has long made early childhood learning the focus of her philanthropic efforts, founding the Royal Foundation Center for Early Childhood in 2021. Her trip to Reggio Emilia was billed by Kensington Palace as a chance for the princess to explore innovative international approaches to nurturing young children.
Outside City Hall, Catherine paused to speak to some of the youngsters, high-fived a little boy, posed for selfies, and waved and smiled to the crowd.
For British royal watchers, the visit signals that Catherine, 44, is ready to more fully return to business as usual more than a year after announcing her cancer was in remission. She did public events last year in Britain, presenting awards, attending functions and watching tennis at Wimbledon. But the trip to Reggio Emilia — with visits to two schools as well as the center where the teaching approach was developed — marks a new level of engagement.
“It’s the first time she’s out officially,” said Richard Fitzwilliams, a British royal commentator. “And she’s obviously grown in strength.”
For Reggio Emilia, the visit was a chance to show off its schools, and itself, basking in a limelight usually reserved for the more famous neighboring cities of Parma and Modena. “It’s the younger brother syndrome,” said Domenico Martino, who works at the city’s tourist office.
Although the city’s innovative schools have long been a draw for tens of thousands of educators, city officials say, celebrity visits are rare.
Reggio Emilia’s educational approach took root after World War II, when local women used the proceeds from the sale of a tank, six horses and some trucks to build a preschool. A network of municipal infant-toddler centers and preschools followed, inspired by Loris Malaguzzi, an education expert intent on making them places of experimentation and innovation.
“The best way to understand Reggio Emilia is to go into the schools,” said Federico Ruozzi, who is in charge of the city’s infant-toddler center and preschool system. “Everyone considers it part of the city’s heritage, and so the families, the administrators, and the children who attended school back then defend it,” he said.
A delegation from Catherine’s foundation quietly visited the city about six weeks ago, taking one of the many courses offered each year by Reggio Children, the organization that promotes the educational approach.
For city officials, that meant a crash course in royal etiquette, including addressing Catherine as Your Royal Highness, said Marwa Mahmoud, the city’s councilor for education.
On Wednesday afternoon, Catherine visited the Scuola Comunale d’Infanzia Anna Frank, a municipal preschool for 3- to 6-year-olds, where she observed an “atelier,” a creative moment for self-expression that is central to the approach. In this case, children interpreted the forms that winds take using different materials and colors, and brainstormed words that clouds bring to mind. Catherine added her own: “Dream,” said Annalisa Rabotti, an education expert who works for the city. “She was very curious and interested and empathetic,” she added.
What is the Reggio Emilia approach?
The so-called Reggio Emilia Approach is an educational philosophy that believes in the potential of young children, from infants to preschoolers, to be creative, learn and thrive in a nurturing environment that involves their families and communities.
The approach became well-known in educational circles after Newsweek featured one of the city’s schools in a 1991 cover piece about the 10 best schools in the world, according to Ms. Mahmoud.
The city’s commitment to the program — it allocates 13 percent of its budget to preschool services, Ms. Mahmoud said — also contributes to its success.
“We’ve always maintained that education — as well as health and health care — should not be viewed as costs. It is right to evaluate them in terms of efficiency and waste reduction, but they are not costs — they are investments in the present and the future,” said Marco Massari, the mayor of Reggio Emilia.
Each school day begins with what Mr. Malaguzzi called “the children’s parliament,” a moment when children are encouraged to speak and listen, and the day’s activities are decided.
The children work in small groups, learning together, “so there are no me and others, but a continuous interaction between the me and the others to build a we,” said Maddalena Tedeschi, president of Reggio Children. They also cook together in in-house kitchens.
Catherine is expected to remain in the city for another day and is expected to visit another school.
Education
‘No Essay’ College Scholarships May Have Unseen Strings Attached
Looking for a college scholarship and finding sites offering easy, “no essay” applications? Beware. Applicants may not realize that they are trading their personal information for what is essentially a raffle ticket.
Unlike traditional scholarships, no-essay prizes often aren’t based on a student’s academic record or other accomplishments. Rather, they are awarded by random drawings, with the odds of winning dependent on how many students apply. The private student lender Sallie Mae, for instance, offers monthly no-essay scholarships of $2,000 through its Scholly search site. The official rules describe the process as a “sweepstakes.”
The same language appears in the rules for no-essay scholarships on other scholarship matching sites, including ScholarshipOwl — which is upfront in estimating, for those who click through to online rules, that the odds of winning are about one in 140,000.
Why offer drawings for scholarships? Online applications can serve as “lead generators” for products like private student loans, said Mark Kantrowitz, a financial-aid expert who years ago helped develop early scholarship-search and financial-aid websites.
Essay-free scholarships do pay out awards. The websites are replete with pictures of happy winners. Jackie Bright, chief executive of the National Scholarship Providers Association, said in an email that “low burden” applications could reduce barriers for students who might not have extra time or writing support at home.
But their potential value to the sites is that applicants provide personal details that the sites may sell — “monetize,” in digital lingo — not just to obvious buyers like colleges and scholarship providers, but also to businesses that want to advertise products and services to students and their families.
“The idea of getting a scholarship is a very tempting reason to provide your personal information,” said R.J. Cross, who directs the “Don’t Sell My Data” campaign for the U.S. Public Interest Research Group.
How has scholarship marketing changed?
Student data has long provided grist for colleges and outside scholarships — those offering awards that don’t come directly from colleges and universities — that want to find interested students. Anyone who has taken the SAT knows that college brochures are sure to appear in the mailbox. But marketing has become more sophisticated in the digital age.
“It’s a really clear example of a power asymmetry between individuals and big data companies,” said Caitriona Fitzgerald, deputy director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center, a Washington research group that aims to protect privacy.
Applicants and their families may not realize just how widely the information they provide to scholarship search sites may be shared or how long it is retained, privacy experts say. As technology advances, the data may be redeployed in ways that weren’t foreseen when it was collected, Ms. Cross said.
ScholarshipOwl’s privacy policy says the site may sell users’ personal information to “other parties.” But David Tabachnikov, the site’s chief executive, said it didn’t sell data to third parties because it earned revenue from user subscription fees. The site’s basic services are free, but users can pay — typically $15 a month — to see more detailed information about scholarships.
Ms. Fitzgerald said it was possible that some sites didn’t currently sell personal data but might do so in the future.
Worries about the use of student data surfaced in a lawsuit that Christopher Gray, who as a college student co-founded Scholly, filed against Sallie Mae last month in Delaware Superior Court.
In July 2023, Sallie Mae said it had acquired the “key assets” of Scholly, which is now part of the company’s SLM Education Services unit. Mr. Gray joined Sallie Mae as an executive but was fired in October 2024 — after, he said in his complaint, he raised privacy objections about the company’s plans to sell information provided to Scholly by students, many of them under 18, to third parties. He said the company had “intentionally” concealed such plans from him.
The suit said Mr. Gray had been wrongfully fired and seeks damages including pay and benefits. The lawsuit was reported earlier by TechCrunch, which covers technology start-ups.
In an interview, Mr. Gray said he was disturbed that the data might be misused to pitch “predatory” credit cards or loans. “It makes me very angry,” he said. “These are students who are very vulnerable.”
Sallie Mae is seeking to dismiss the suit, saying in a brief filed on May 1 that Mr. Gray was fired because he was spending too much time on a new start-up. The brief also said he was spreading “misleading and baseless accusations” as part of a strategy to “improperly use media pressure to extract a monetary settlement.”
Sallie Mae added that it was “fully compliant with all applicable privacy laws and regulations.”
Richard Castellano, a Sallie Mae spokesman, said in an email that Education Services tried selling limited student data as part of a pilot last year but discontinued the strategy in mid-2025. “We are not selling personal information to third parties today and have no intention to do so,” he said.
Still, the privacy policy that applies to Education Services lists a wide swath of personal information that the company may collect, starting with basic items like your name and email and mailing address. But it may also include things like your date of birth and more sensitive information, like your Social Security number, driver’s license number, race, ethnicity and sexual orientation.
The site may potentially share this personal information, the policy says, with partners and business customers, including those “that want to market to you,” and may enter into agreements with third parties to “sell or license information to them for their own purposes.”
Sallie Mae — which has begun calling its overall business Sallie — recently created its own advertising arm, Backpack Media, which helps translate consumer data into targeted ads. The unit has hired digital advertising specialists and said its “proprietary education and audience insights” could help companies reach students at key moments, such graduating from high school, choosing a college and starting a first job. “We know who students and recent grads are, where they’re headed and what they’ll need next,” the website says.
Backpack Media does not sell individuals’ data, and its partners do not get access to any personal information, Mr. Castellano said.
Can I check how a site uses my information?
Take time to read a scholarship site’s privacy policy, experts say. Search for words like “collect,” “sell,” “share” and “disclose.”
Such tedious, site-by-site research wouldn’t be necessary if the United States had a national, comprehensive digital privacy policy, Ms. Fitzgerald said. The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act, from 1998, applies only to children under 13. States are starting to pass their own privacy laws, she said, but protections vary.
If what you learn on a site makes you uncomfortable, see if it offers a way to opt out of having certain information shared or sold. If you can’t opt out, try another site with policies that limit the sale of information.
In general, it’s best to limit sharing your information, Ms. Cross said. The more widely it is spread, the more vulnerable it is to being compromised.
What other steps can I take?
Creating a separate email account specifically for scholarship search sites can help. That way, if your information is shared or sold, promotions or pitches will go to that email rather than clogging your main email account.
Education
Look Up Your School District’s Test Scores
About the data
The test score data for third- through eighth-graders in traditional public school districts comes from the Educational Opportunity Project at Stanford. A report on the new data was released on May 13 by the Education Scorecard, a joint project by Sean Reardon at the Stanford group; Thomas Kane at the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard; and Doug Staiger at Dartmouth.
Researchers linked state test results with the results of a federal exam, the National Assessment of Educational Progress, to allow for comparisons across states. States were excluded if they allowed families to opt out of tests, recently updated their tests or were otherwise missing data.
Researchers identified districts in the same state that were similar in size, demographics and type of community, such as urban, suburban or rural.
This tool includes data for medium and large districts where scores were available. For districts missing 2015 data, The Times used an average of 2014 and 2016 scores as a baseline.
-
Finance2 minutes agoCrystal City ISD laying off 25% of staff amid financial crisis
-
Fitness8 minutes ago‘I’m a neuroscientist – these are the 3 best workouts for slowing cognitive decline’
-
Movie Reviews20 minutes agoKaruppu (Veerabhadrudu) Movie Review – Gulte
-
World32 minutes ago
Supreme Court rejects Virginia’s bid to restore congressional map favoring Democrats
-
News38 minutes agoTop Drug Regulator Is Fired From the F.D.A.
-
Politics44 minutes agoVideo: Why Were These C.E.O.s in Beijing With Trump?
-
Business50 minutes agoWhat Trump Gained, and Didn’t, From China
-
Health1 hour agoMicro-Walking Plan for Weight Loss: Harvard Doctor Calls It a ‘Wonder Drug’