South
Susan Campbell (opinion): Let’s have debate clubs for adults
I wish I’d joined my high school debate club. At the time, I’d already collected a drawerful of nerd ribbons and I worried that my thin popularity would collapse under the weight of one more.
Still, I admired the briefcases carried by the members of my school’s debate team, who did quite well, if memory serves. I also liked their index cards, which they would rifle through in a debate as if the world depended on their finding the right one.
Maybe those of us who were too cool for debate club bear some of the blame for the current state of U.S. social discourse. We missed a wonderful opportunity to learn how to discuss issues in a meaningful way.
A new study says that middle- and high school students who belong to debate clubs tend to be better at critical thinking (a much-needed skill) and after graduation, those students are more likely to attend college.
But the rest of us? We appear to have lost — if we ever possessed — the ability to engage in civil discussions. If you tuned in to Fox for last week’s Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis/California Gov. Gavin Newsom televised debate/rumble, you probably walked away disappointed. I tuned in and was reminded that just because there’s a circus in town doesn’t mean I have to buy a ticket. Then, too, if you appoint Sean Hannity as moderator of a debate that covered topics such as homelessness, taxes, immigration and abortion, you should keep expectations low. Of course, this was a political debate, so our expectations weren’t very high in the first place. Political debate is theater and the news coverage mostly keeps track of who dominated what conversation, with bonus points if you humiliate your opponent.
At least the fact-checkers earned their paychecks that night, and bless them.
This may be patently unfair, but compare last week’s performance (“You’re a liar,” “No, YOU are”) with the 1858 Lincoln/Douglas debates. Republican Abraham Lincoln and incumbent U.S. Sen. Stephen Douglas (a Democrat) went head to head in a series of seven debates about the most controversial issue of their time — slavery and the expansion thereof. The stakes were high and what ended up being 21 hours of debate set the tone of other debates that would drive policy.
You can read the transcripts of the debates — which were later published in a book. The language includes such gems as Lincoln’s imploring that “A house divided against itself cannot stand,” which he borrowed from a Christian scripture (Matthew 12:25) people would have recognized.
The debates helped send Douglas (who argued that territories should decide whether to allow slavery) back to Washington, but it put the nation on notice that Lincoln was a politician who bore watching, and it reminded the populace that the debate about slavery wasn’t going away.
Compare that to select statements from last week’s show:
“…one thing, in closing, that we have in common is that neither of us will be the nominee for our party in 2024.” — Gavin Newsom
“You have the freedom to defecate in public in California.” — Ron DeSantis
“I don’t want to be the hall monitor. Please don’t turn me into that.” — Sean Hannity.
Who won? Who cares? That was not debate. It was an online argument read aloud as bad spoken word poetry.
In fact, these days, most debates exist entirely on social media. They go thus:
- Someone posts something controversial and often unlinked to reality
- A second party refutes the post
- Name-calling ensues
- Someone mutes or blocks their “debate” partner
And that’s it, a very modern and useless exercise in which we risk and learn nothing. Since social media is not the venue for serious debate, let’s consider moving back to real-live, face-to-face conversations with debate clubs. Our democracy is hungry for it.
So: Resolved: In-person debate clubs for grown-ups shall be organized in every Connecticut town starting in the new year. Attendance isn’t mandatory, but there will be door prizes. We need to learn (or relearn) how to talk to people with whom we don’t agree.
Last week, we went to an area library to listen to a Connecticut College professor talk about Palestine, as in how we got here. This was no debate, per se, but there was a lot of information shared by a credible source. From the questions afterward, it was obvious there was some disagreement, but the conversation remained respectful and fruitful. We were face to face, after all, and though we continually find ourselves learning new social norms, calling someone an idiot to his/her/their face remains rude.
We drove home excited to have been out in public (like during Before Times) to participate in a real-life talk about an important issue. It felt like a throwback. It felt necessary. It felt great. I’d be willing to argue for a debate club for adults, though I probably wouldn’t do so effectively. Maybe I can hire a young debater, who would most likely know best.
Susan Campbell is the author of “Frog Hollow: Stories from an American Neighborhood,” “Tempest-Tossed: The Spirit of Isabella Beecher Hooker” and “Dating Jesus: A Story of Fundamentalism, Feminism and the American Girl.” She is Distinguished Lecturer at the University of New Haven, where she teaches journalism.
![](https://newspub.live/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/np-logo.png)
Arkansas
Cody Rhodes uses Arkansas-Pine Bluff marching band to fuel his WWE title defense
![Cody Rhodes uses Arkansas-Pine Bluff marching band to fuel his WWE title defense Cody Rhodes uses Arkansas-Pine Bluff marching band to fuel his WWE title defense](https://a.espncdn.com/combiner/i?img=%2Fphoto%2F2024%2F0831%2Fr1380346_1296x729_16%2D9.jpg)
Though the Arkansas Razorbacks won on the field against the Arkansas-Pine Bluff Golden Lions, the Golden Lions’ band won the fans in the stands.
On Thursday, the Arkansas-Pine Bluff band — named the “Marching Musical Machine of the Mid-South” — performed a rendition of WWE star Cody Rhodes’ theme song, “Kingdom,” during the game.
Rhodes fought Kevin Owens in the undisputed WWE title match at the Bash in Berlin on Saturday. Rhodes defeated Owens to remain the undisputed WWE champion. Prior to his match, Rhodes heard the band’s rendition of his theme song and expressed his excitement about the performance. He said he would play the band’s version once or twice in the locker room.
Berlin had me already fired up for #WWEBash
But THIS may be played once or twice in the locker room before my match today.
Awesome stuff @UAPBM4 ❤️ https://t.co/cYA5lcG8Lw
— Cody Rhodes (@CodyRhodes) August 31, 2024 The band’s full performance went viral on X and received over 866,000 views as of Saturday evening. Arkansas-Pine Bluff director of bands John Graham said the band members were doubtful at first once they received the piece in practice. But as they rehearsed the song, they began to love it.
“When our arranger put the song on paper for us, I looked at it [and] some of the students were shaking their heads thinking, ‘No, why are we playing this’ and then we started rehearsing it, the piece came alive,” Graham told ESPN.
“I said, ‘This is going to go.’”
“Kingdom” wasn’t arranged for the Golden Lions-Razorbacks game, but instead as a piece that could be used later in the season. However, Graham saw the Arkansas game as the perfect opportunity to debut the song in the stands.
When Graham gave the downbeat for the band to play the song, excitement filled the stadium. “As soon as I dropped the hammer and we started playing, I looked over and saw fans reacting like, ‘They’re playing “Kingdom,”‘” Graham said. “I saw them standing up with excitement and positive reactions, and I told myself, ‘We’re in here now.’ It was a beautiful moment.”
Delaware
Missing Delaware fisherman missed call with family; Coast Guard asks for help
![Missing Delaware fisherman missed call with family; Coast Guard asks for help Missing Delaware fisherman missed call with family; Coast Guard asks for help](https://cdn.abcotvs.com/dip/images/15252935_083124-wpvi-missing-fisherman-2-img.jpeg?w=1600)
REHOBOTH BAY, Delaware (WPVI) — The U.S. Coast Guard is asking for the public’s help in locating a missing Delaware fisherman who was last seen earlier this week.
Officials are searching for 46-year-old Dorian Yanke. He last spoke with family members on Monday around 7:30 a.m.
During the phone call, he reportedly informed family members he was going on a fishing trip in the vicinity of Rehoboth Bay, Delaware.
U.S. Coast Guard Mid-Atlantic
The Coast Guard says he missed a call with family members on Tuesday. He was then reported missing the next day.
Yanke is about 6 feet tall and weighs roughly 200 pounds.
He was last seen wearing a tan shirt, navy shorts, and a navy ball cap.
Anyone with information is asked to call the Sector Delaware Bay Command Center 24/7 hotline at 215-271-4960.
Copyright © 2024 WPVI-TV. All Rights Reserved.
Florida
College football games, scores, updates: Miami vs. Florida, Ohio State vs. Akron and more
It’s the Saturday of Labor Day weekend, which means the full chaos of college football has truly arrived.
There were 21 games on Thursday — including Colorado’s win against perennial FCS powerhouse North Dakota State — and six games Friday before a full slate on Saturday.
No. 1 Georgia got things started with an absolute show of force, blasting No. 14 Clemson 34-3 in their season opener. Heisman favorite Carson Beck was on point throughout, throwing for 278 yards and two touchdowns in the win.
The nightcap is a showdown between No. 7 Notre Dame and No. 20 Texas A&M.
(All times are Eastern.)
Time: 7:30 p.m. | TV: ABC | Line: Texas A&M -3 | Total: 46.5
Notre Dame doesn’t shy away from tough openers, and this is no exception. Saturday night is QB Riley Leonard’s first game in a Notre Dame uniform after transferring to Duke, but he’ll be playing behind a revamped offensive line that lost three starters from 2023. First-year Texas A&M coach Mike Elko brings a defense that has lots of new faces but is still plenty talented. And QB Connor Weigman returns as the Aggies’ starting quarterback with the goal of staying healthy for the whole season.
Live92 updates
-
Connecticut1 week ago
Oxford church provides sanctuary during Sunday's damaging storm
-
Technology1 week ago
Breakthrough robo-glove gives you superhuman grip
-
Politics1 week ago
Clinton lauds Biden as modern-day George Washington and president who 'healed our sick' in DNC speech
-
Politics1 week ago
2024 showdown: What happens next in the Kamala Harris-Donald Trump face-off
-
News1 week ago
Who Are Kamala Harris’s 1.5 Million New Donors?
-
Politics1 week ago
Trump taunted over speculated RFK Jr endorsement: 'Weird as hell'
-
Politics1 week ago
Vivek Ramaswamy sounds off on potential RFK Jr. role in a Trump administration
-
World6 days ago
Portugal coast hit by 5.3 magnitude earthquake