In the compelling German suspense story I Is Another (Ich ist ein Anderer), protean Danish polyglot Claes Bang stars as Felix Kersten, an actual physiotherapist/masseur who claimed he was instrumental in persuading his client Heinrich Himmler to let Jewish prisoners go at the end of World War II but whose account remains disputed to this day. Writer-director Felix Randau finds an economical way to distill the mystery around the attractive but clearly egomaniacal Kersten by putting him in conversation on a train with Valerie Pachner’s fictional East German journalist, a woman with her own shady past.
The combustible onscreen chemistry of Bang (The Northman, Cannes Palme d’Or winner The Square, Apple TV’s Bad Sisters) and Pachner (Mata Hari in The King’s Man) represents a major selling point for this sly study of deception and delusion, one that feels eerily relevant in these “post-truth” times. Premiering in Locarno’s Piazza Grande, I Is Another could stretch its legs commercially with niche distributors beyond Germany.
I Is Another
The Bottom Line
Advertisement
Truth is elusive.
Venue: Locarno Film Festival (Piazza Grande) Cast: Claes Bang, Valerie Pachner, Susanne Wuest, Timocin Ziegler, Martin Mueller, Michael Fuith, Till Firit, Christoph Mueller Director-screenwriter: Felix Randau
1 hour 33 minutes
Although the action flashes back periodically to the war years, most of the plot unfolds in a series of cramped cabins on a train bound for Oslo in 1952 on which Kersten is traveling, accompanied by his chirpy, bird-like wife Irmgard (a vivid Susanne Wuest, who co-starred in Randau’s earlier feature Iceman).
Advertisement
They are on their way to Norway to attend the press conference announcing candidates for that year’s Nobel Peace Prize, full of expectations that Felix is being considered for securing the release of concentration camp inmates in the Spring of 1945. This freeing of Scandinavian prisoners, also known as the White Buses incident, was (and is) generally credited to the intervention of Swedish Red Cross president Folke Bernadotte, who negotiated directly with Himmler.
In 1952, Kersten published a letter allegedly written by Bernadotte that painted the latter in a very unflattering light while making Kersten look like the real hero, a plot point incorporated into the script here in a way that’s not strictly historically accurate.
But that all happens later in the film. At the opening, unbeknownst to the Kerstens, another couple has booked the cabin next to them: Hedda (Pachner) and Winfried Wohmann (Timocin Ziegler), a reporter and photographer, respectively, from the German Democratic Republic. Hedda, clad in a blouse whose stripes reflect the zigs and zags of the plot’s twists and has a Rosalind Russell in His Girl Friday vibe, launches a charm offensive to persuade Kersten to give her an interview.
The flattery and fluttering eyelashes work, and they settle down in his cabin with a vintage reel-to-reel tape recorder to go over his story, shown in flashbacks. Kersten describes how he came to treat SS Reich Leader Himmler (played with aptly martinetish froideur by Christoph Mueller) for chronic stomach pain. Over time, he gained the Nazi’s confidence, although Kersten insists he was never an employee of the SS as such or even a member of the Nazi Party.
Hedda and Felix’s interview is interrupted when he is summoned to take a phone call, giving her a chance to rummage around in his luggage for evidence of her suspicions, revealed earlier in a conversation with Winfried, that Kersten is not telling the whole truth. When Kersten catches her red-handed looking for his diary, he insists she take it away, read it and judge his honesty for herself.
Advertisement
His persuasive written testimony may seed in Hedda some small doubts about her previous doubts, but as she explains to Winfried, the diary could easily have been written years after the events it describes. As the interview resumes, she reveals knowledge of details that contradict his account, enraging the bearish Baltic German who reveals a violent streak under all that urbanity and command of five languages.
Bang is perfectly cast for the role, on account both of his own linguistic skills and his looming stature, creating a strong contrast with Pachner’s slight, elfin figure. When he bangs his fist on the rickety table and raises his voice, it looks like the next minute he might hit her or drag her to bed — either outcome seems possible.
Plus, it turns out that Hedda, her name echoing that of Henrik Ibsen’s famously complex character, is no exemplar of honesty herself. A scandal in her recent career resulted in her and Winfried being internally exiled from Berlin to provincial Halle, and she’s clearly hoping a big scoop will put her back in favor. Winfried has become an alcoholic, tortured by the memory of atrocities he committed as a soldier during the war. Hedda has her own personal history she’d like forgotten.
Unfortunately, Kersten, with his connections to Swedish intelligence, finds out more than she’d like about her background, so their conversation turns into a game of tit for tat, threats and counterthreats.
Randau orchestrates these shifts in power well, building up suspense with strong assists from editor Joana Scrinzi and an understated score by Bernhard Fleischmann. Nevertheless, the way the script is structured as a series of two-handers lends a theatrical air to the proceedings, not necessarily a bad thing in itself, though something other viewers might fidget through. But the considerable charisma of the main leads carries the feature along and makes this a work that feels more substantial and weighty than the footnote in history it might have played like in the hands of a different cast and director.
Should you see it, skip it, or stream it? Ryan Jay gives us his movie ratings! This week he reviews:
By Any Means / Paramount Pictures Fall 2: Deadpoint / Lionsgate
Ryan also shares details on the new Ryan Jay Movie Club happening Wednesday, September 9 at 7 p.m. Plus, enter to win a pair of free tickets at RyanJayReviews.com
Ryan has an exciting giveaway featuring the Ultimate OZ Universe books and shares his contribution included in the collection. Enter to win both volumes at RyanJayReviews.com
Advertisement
And don’t miss Ryan’s free movie screening event at the Argo
Masked soldiers deployed on domestic soil and an air of conspiratorial paranoia give Adam Wingard’s not-quite-grindhouse siege film Onslaught a contemporary pulse, even if this lean, B-movie thriller doesn’t deliver much more than a flicker of its throwback promise.
Wingard, though, does seem freshly liberated in this return to his low-budget thriller roots ( You’re Next, The Guest). He has since spent the last decade in more IP-managed releases: the 2016 Blair Witch sequel, a Netflix adaptation of Death Note and a pair of Godzilla vs. Kong movies.
But the 92-minute Onslaught, written by Wingard and his regular collaborator Simon Barrett, is intentionally straightforward — to the point, you could say, of brainlessness. It’s aiming for a very simple slasher setup in the mould of John Carpenter: A single mom and PTSD-riddled former Army sniper, Celeste (Adria Arjona), living in a desert trailer park, defends herself and her young daughter (Blake Kennedy) from an invasion of three highly programmed super-soldiers who have sprung out of a nearby military contractor facility.
Advertisement
Even though Onslaught begins with a clock that’s already ticking below 12 hours, the movie takes its time leading to a bloody finale that isn’t quite worth the drumbeat. But Wingard is in no great hurry, and he lingers in the anticipation, for better and for worse.
So early on we get Dan Stevens (deliberately hammy) as a suspiciously old, white-haired Nazi scientist crawling across the room to lick the stiletto-heeled foot of his wife and co-conspirator (a queenly Rebecca Hall, suggesting great depth in her few minutes on screen). From the bodies of dead soldiers, Stevens’ mad scientist has engineered three elite killing machines. They are devoid of personality, with beady lights for eyes. Still, he’s given them nicknames: the Butcher (Alex Pereira), the Cockroach (Dave Campbell) and the Crybaby (Tyler Hall).
They get out, of course, and begin causing trouble. Onslaught likewise lingers on the quickly dispatched operative, Cyrus (Drew Starkey), sent to clean up the ensuing mess. Wingard delights in introducing the character, who’s more drugged up and charmingly laid-back than your usual cleanup expert. It’s a lot of set-up for a guy who, ultimately, doesn’t do much.
But what’s the rush? Wingard also takes his time surveying the female bodies at the S&M club Cyrus is attending when we meet him, just as he does looking over some of the bloody wreckage left by the super-soldiers. He even, momentarily, takes one of their perspectives in a random killing at a gas station convenience store — a point of view that’s hard to justify, considering there’s no other attempt to consider the inner horrors of the brain-dead soldiers.
They start unleashing mayhem across a Western plain that looks like it could either be where Wile E. Coyote chases the Roadrunner or the setting of Chloé Zhao’s Nomadland.
Advertisement
Onslaught has a bit of both. The movie is best in its leisurely depiction of life at the Windy Oasis, the trailer-park remove where Celeste has found some rough-hewn sense of peace — away from society and with plenty of room for target practice.
Reginald VelJohnson and Eric Wareheim gamely play Celeste’s neighbours, adding to the eccentric ensemble. But Onslaught is most of all a chance for Arjona, a supporting standout in Hit Man and Splitsville, to show some leading-woman grit. And she does that in Wingard’s quirkily contradictory movie: gleefully violent despite its military satire, curiously unhurried despite its title.
Onslaught, an A24 release is rated A-18 for strong bloody violence, some gore, sexual material/nudity, and language. It is coming soon to theatres.
Hollywood has given us some classic mismatched buddy cop movies, like Nick Nolte and Eddie Murphy in “48 Hrs.,” Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker in “Rush Hour” and perhaps the most iconic pair — Mel Gibson and Danny Glover in “Lethal Weapon.” Now, make room for Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Mark Wahlberg.
The latest duo stars in “By Any Means,” an opposites-attract movie with real historical heft, set against the racial and political violence of the American South in the late 1960s and told with blood-splashing power and blunt elegance, courtesy of director Elegance Bratton.
Here we get Abdul-Mateen as a by-the-book, Southern-born, wet-behind-the-ears, Black FBI agent teamed up with Wahlberg, a jaundiced New York Mafia hitman, two characters crossing the racial, North-South and polite barriers.
Unable to crack the 1966 firebombing murder of Mississippi NAACP leader Vernon Dahmer Sr., the FBI turns to Wahlberg’s Gregory Scarpa, letting him loose off the books to solve the case. The Ku Klux Klan is everywhere, especially in law enforcement, and that means Scarpa’s got to crack some skulls, no warrant, no problem. “Nobody can know,” the pair are warned.
Advertisement
Bratton and scriptwriter Sascha Penn artfully straddle the various divides and historical animosities while delivering a propulsive, muscular and unvarnished action thriller, a sort of “Mississippi Burning” for a new generation. And, it must be noted, at a time when white Christian nationalism has once more reared its ugly head.
“By Any Means” is one of those “based on true events” movies that gives the filmmakers the chance to have their nonfiction cake and eat it fictionally, too. While it might seem historically fanciful that J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI ever called in a hitman to hunt the KKK, Scarpa was a real guy, an FBI informant enlisted amid intense pressure to solve the murders of three civil rights workers in Mississippi. It’s his FBI buddy who never existed, a “composite,” as the press materials note.
So full credit to Abdul-Mateen, who has created a complex, charismatic character from thin air, taking his agent Wayne Strider on a slow-burn trip from all tucked-in, waiting-outside respectfully to car-chasing, gun-shooting revenge-fantasy hero.
This image released by Paramount Pictures shows Mark Wahlberg, left, and Yahya Abdul-Mateen II in a scene from “By Any Means.” Credit: AP/Eli Ade
Wahlberg, meanwhile, grips every external item we know of Scarpa and holds onto them for dear life: An ever-present toothpick in mouth, a prosthetic nose, a mop of ungainly hair, a white tank top, sunglasses even at night. Wahlberg has apparently rewatched “The Sopranos” a lot.
Advertisement
The movie is buoyed by an amazing supporting cast, like the terrific Nicole Beharie as Strider’s wife, LisaGay Hamilton as a key witness and Giancarlo Esposito as Dahmer. The pastel costumes and bulging, chrome cars are gorgeous. The soundtrack features Nina Simone, Ray Charles, Dinah Washington, Curtis Mayfield, and an anthemic title jam by Diane Warren, performed by the Isley Brothers and David Kushner.
It’s the interaction between the hitman and the FBI agent that’s at the heart of the movie, along with the lingering question of whether violence can ever be a corrective. The Mafia guy’s methods — smashing skulls, breaking bones with a baseball bat, putting guns into mouths — stun his partner. And while the violence gets a bit excessive, it’s kind of thrilling to see gutless KKK members beaten to a bloody pulp over and over.
Scarpa is a fascinating alien in rural Mississippi, a slab of Italian American muscle who stands outside the racial divide. He’s just there to do a job, nothing more. But when asked what he’d do if he ever faced such racial animus, he replies: “I’d kill them all, every last one of them.”
This image released by Paramount Pictures shows Yahya Abdul-Mateen II in a scene from “By Any Means.” Credit: AP/Daniel McFadden
Our FBI agent isn’t impressed. He despises his Mafia partner so much that, if forced to choose between him and the KKK, he knows which way he’d lean: “At least they believe in something.”
The tension between the two men boils over into a “48 Hrs.”- style, knock-down fistfight. At this point, the movie veers off the rails a bit, culminating in a very bloody conclusion. But that doesn’t dim the introduction of a very effective new movie cop pairing — Abdul-Mateen and Wahlberg.
Advertisement
“By Any Means,” a Paramount Pictures release in theaters starting Sept. 4, is rated R by the Motion Picture Association for “violence/bloody images and pervasive language.” Running time: 107 minutes. Three stars out of four.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login